Hybrid Control Systems


The Question & Answer

by
A H Ahmad Kamil
H W Chui


Select your answers by clicking the diamonds

Question 1


There are three types of control systems namely discrete (logical), continuous- time and hybrid. How are these control systems categorised?


next question

Answer



Question 2


What is the fundamental result of a hybrid control system?


next question

Answer



Question 3


Control programs that integrate logical and continuum models, i.e. hybrid control programs, work well for small scale systems. Unfortunately, there are two main implications for large scale systems. Which of these combinations is the right one?

i. increase in cost
ii. increase in respond time
iii. decrease in reliability



next question

Answer



For question 4 and 5, please refer to the text below.

A logic control system is basically governed by IF .. THEN statements, i.e. logic rules. In addition, the system is easily implemented using Boolean logic, very reliable and economical. Generally, control programs use computer machines where the language used supports only logical functions. All logic rules are stored in the machine's database. Anyway, for more effective control, a logic-only control systems may need to be converted into a hybrid control system.

Go to Question 5

Question 4


Why is this conversion necessary?

next question

Answer



Question 5


The basic principle of the conversion would be

i. increase the machine's database.
ii. replacing the huge-in-size logical rules with a suitable continuous function. The programmer for the machine is responsible for obtaining this function
iii. replacing the language used with one that supports both logical and continuous functions.


refer to the text

next question

Answer


Question 6


Which of the following applications use hybrid control systems for better control?

i. Aerospace vehicles
ii. Power grids
iii. Automated intelligent control
iv. Air traffic management systems

next question

Answer


Question 7


Why are hybrid control systems difficult to model?
next question

Answer


Question 8


Which of the following techniques can solve some of the difficulties in hybrid systems modelling?
next question

Answer


Question 9


In Which of the following systems is/are considered a hybrid system?

i. A continuous system
ii. A logic system
iii.A discrete system
iv. A mixture of logic and continuous systems
next question

Answer


Question 10


What is the main reason for hybrid systems' enormous applications?
A. It involves computer-aided control
B. Almost every system is a hybrid system
C. Flexibility, adaptation and learning arise from hybrid system.
D. Stability and optimality and adaptiveness can easily be achieved by hybrid systems.

next question

Answer


Question 11


What are the "Multiple Views" of the control engineering problem of User, Design Engineer and System Engineer?
Answer


To find out how well you have done, click We will send you the result as soon as possible. Thank you for your time.

The Answer Zone

Note:

Please make sure that you have tried first those questions before looking into the correct answers.


Question 1
Answer: C

This is the basic question to categorise a control system. Definitely the correct answer depends on the type of signals the system processes. The range of times when the system was developed and/or the response time of the system are totally irrelevant

Return to Question 1

Question 2
Answer: B

The fundamental result of a hybrid control system simultaneously complies with both logical and continuous-time constraints. There is no priority of which constraints must be complied with first. The reaction which is taken is not necessarily independent from both constraints. In controlling the water level of a tank as an example,(please refer to Ahmad Kamil's Article2 ) only ONE reaction is enough which is to turn the tap at an appropriate angle.

Return to Question 2

Question 3
Answer: C

The incorrect choice is ii. A hybrid control system is actually trying to reduce the response time. This can be done by converting a logic control system to be hybrid. Please refer to questions 4 and 5 for more details of this conversion.

Return to Question 3

Question 4
Answer: C

It is true that hybrid systems are the latest in control technology but generally it is still under development. In addition, converting into a hybrid control system does not make more effective a particular system especially when the system has very few conditions or situations to be considered. Using a logic control system in this case is better. Furthermore, a hybrid control system is relatively less reliable and less economical (refer to question 1). From the given text, for a logic control system to be more effective, more logic rules need to be added in the machine's database that, on the other hand, will increase the response time. Converting into a hybrid is then necessary.

Return to Question 4

Question 5
Answer: C

The right steps of the conversion are

  1. substitute with a language used in the machine that supports both logical and continuous functions. This is vital since the fundamental result of a hybrid control system simultaneously complies with both logical and continuous- time constraints (refer to question 2).
  2. please note that many logic rules have to be outlined that cover every possible situations. what the programmer need to do to convert into a hybrid control system is to replace the huge-in-size logic rules with a suitable continuous function.
Therefore ii and iii are the right answers.

Return to Question 5

Question 6
Answer: D

Actually all alternatives can be implemented using a mixture of discrete and continuous control systems i.e. a hybrid. Unstable very high performance systems such as the above alternatives will benefit from the flexibility of hybrid systems, since different control laws can be imposed to make the system behave acceptably in successive time intervals[2].

Return to Question 6

Question 7
Answer: B

Combining logic and continuous systems requires the knowledge of a variety of mathematical and engineering disciplines such as differential geometry, automata(programs) theory, differential and difference equations, optimal control, discrete event systems, data structures and computation[2]. A unified theory did not exist at all 10 years ago. Hybrid systems is currently an active area of research in control theory and computer science but a fully mature theory is still a few years off.

Return to Question 7

Question 8
Answer: A

Anil Nerode and Wolf Kohn have proposed MAHCA[1] which is based on extensions to the theory of relaxed variational control. Basically, they use this relaxed calculus of variations to extract finite control automata, which guarantee an approximately optimal performance.

Return to Question 8

Question 9
Answer: C

First of all the interaction of logic and continuous elements in real system can not be decomposed into disjoint logic and continuous elements. A discrete system is a very special case of a hybrid systems. The procedure of discrete systems can be continualised with improved performance advantages.

Return to Question 9

Question 10
Answer: C

They allow for the improvement on the traditional control and estimation technologies by providing computationally effective methodologies for the implementation of digital programs that design or modify the control law in response to sensor detected events, or as a result for adaptation and learning.

Return to Question 10

Question 11
Answer: A

A.Nerode and W.Kohn proposed method(MAHCA)[1] on complex optimization problems. They developed a Computer-Aided Control Engineering(CACE) architecture to solve the disagreement between different disciplines over the development of control systems. They arranged the responsibilites of the players in the solution of control engineering.

Return to Question 11

References


  1. Wolf Kohn, John James, Anil Nerode, Karan Harbison and Ashok Agrawala."A Hybrid Systems Approach to Computer Aided Control Engineering," IEEE Control Systems, April 1995, pp. 14-25.
  2. Anil Nerode, Wolf Kohn."Models for Hybrid Systrem: Automata, Topologies, Controllability, Observability". Lecture Notes in Computer Science: Hybrid Systems. Springer-Verlag, 1993, pp. 317-356.